Call or Text716-697-3560 For Your Free Quote

Updated: 12/2023

Carrigan Painting

716-697-3560

Learn about Plaster Repair and/or Drywall Repair from a local expert.
We also paint most of our repair work.
In 2023 about 80% of our work was plaster & drywall repair related.
Scroll down for a small sample of our plaster repair work in the Buffalo suburbs.


We do not work in the City of Buffalo
Carrigan Painting portfolio image of plaster ceiling repair and painting - Amherst, NY
Plaster ceiling damage from a plumbing leak, with custom texture. We repaired the hole with real plaster, and painted the ceiling - Amherst NY
Carrigan Painting portfolio image of Plaster ceiling repair
This plaster ceiling was damaged by heat from the kitchen light. The previous homeowner likely used 2, 60-100+ watt light bulbs in the light fixture and literally baked the plaster finish coat off the ceiling.
Carrigan Painting portfolio image of plaster crack repair
This home in Amherst NY had a bunch of cracks in the plaster walls and ceiling. We chipped out the cracks with a hatchet to give the new plaster more to 'key' into. With plaster repair, you only apply material to the damaged area. Plaster shrinks very little so there is no need to build it up. When you run your finger over the joint between the existing surface and the plaster patch there should be no bump.
Carrigan Painting portfolio image of plaster repair of ceiling and wall in Clarence NY
Major water leak in this Clarence Hollow home. 2 ceilings here, the original plaster ceiling and then a drywall ceiling over the top. It is sometimes cheaper & easier to cover a damaged plaster ceiling with new drywall than fix the damage. However if water damage is involved, the water damaged plaster/drywall should be removed prior to hanging new board.
Carrigan Painting portfolio image of plaster ceiling patch
Repaired a plaster ceiling bulge in this Williamsville home. Its important to note, that the size of a plaster bulge repair can increase exponentially onces the bulge is removed. The reason being is that often the plaster keys holding the plaster to the ceiling/wall around the bulge are often broken, necessitating the removal of it as well. The bulge removed in the repair above was 1/3 the size of the patch.
Carrigan Painting portfolio image of water damaged plaster ceiling and wall repaired with real plaster
This was the result of a small water leak. The corrosion is called Efflorescence which is a condition where (salt) deposits (in the form of a fluffy white powder) form on the plaster surface. All efflorescence must be removed prior to applying new material or there is a risk of re-starting the chemical process that caused the efflorescencein the first place. White vinegar liberally applied to the surface will often nuetralize the chemical reaction.
Carrigan Painting portfolio image of water damage plaster ceiling repair in Amherst NY
Water damage plaster ceiling repair in Amherst NY. The only reason we did not open the cracks on this job is because the ceilings and walls in this home are made out of cement. Our attempts to fix the cracks would actually make the situation worse. So we opted to try to hide them instead. This house was a first for us. Its not every day where every tool in your truck used for repair work barely chips the surface!
Carrigan Painting portfolio image of water damaged plaster crown molding repair
This plaster crown molding was damaged due to a water leak around a chimney. A common location for water damage to ceilings in WNY. We removed the water damaged plaster and rebuilt the crown on site using real plaster. The pink stuff is a bonding agent. It premotes adhesion of the new plaster to the old plaster after its applied. This was the most interesting, but difficult 5 feet.
Carrigan Painting portfolio image of Right way vs wrong way to fix plaster cracks and drywall cracks
This is an example of how not to fix plaster cracks. The 'repair' on the left is relying completely on the bad adhesion of the ceiling paint. This is an example of a waste of time and money. The plaster ceiling above the ceiling paint (green) is free to move as the previous attempt at the ceiling crack repair does not actually attach to the plaster ceiling at any point. The other mistake, is the lack of material prior to laying the mesh tape.Contrary to popular belief, material will not magically connect on the backside of mesh tape if only applied to one side. -a pet peeve

On the right, we chipped out the crack and opened it up. After this picture was taken, we scraped off the loose paint, and repaired the crack properly. Mesh tape thats installed properly doesn't come off. Or it comes off in pieces!

Which repair do you think will last longer?

Carrigan Painting portfolio image of plaster bulge on ceiling repaired.
A fairly large plaster bulge on this plaster ceiling that someone else attampted to fix. They laid mesh tape then applied drywall compound over the top. As you can see it held up wonderfully. Unfortunately, this plaster ceiling was no longer actually attached to anything. Once we knocked a hole in it, we removed the rest by hand - no tools! Once the old plaster was removed, we installed metal lath over the wood lath, applied plaster base coat to the metal lath, then applied a lime and Plaster of Paris finish.
Plaster ceiling repair in Amherst, NY
Large water leak in this Amherst home. The homeowner thought they had fixed the leak, however upon removing the water damaged plaster we discovered wetness. So we set up all of our fans and had to put the entire job on hold for a week so it could dry and they could fix the leak. We will not knowingly repair a ceiling, that has an active water leak.

Plaster Ceiling Repair

Due to water damage

Since 2010, Carrigan Painting has been providing 5 star rated plaster repairs for mostly Amherst & Clarence homeowners. We have a growing library of our past projects including video. Within this website, the owner of Carrigan Painting, shares his extensive industry experience and closely guarded trade secrets, to explain the intricacies of plaster repair and drywall repair.

There are very few plasterers left in Western New York, and even fewer who offer professional painting services after the plaster repairs are completed. We paint almost all of our repair work saving our clients the hassle of having to hire 2 different contractors for one project. In 2023, the majority of our work was drywall and plaster repair related.

Call Carrigan Painting Today!

716-697-3560

Free Plaster Repair Quote


We do not work in the City of Buffalo

Would you prefer we contact you?