Call or Text 716-697-3560 Today!

Lancaster NY Painting Services
716-697-3560

Recent Projects in Lancaster NY

For some reason some thumbnails wont load. Not sure why.

Drywall Ceiling Repair and Painting in Pine Tree Farms, Lancaster NY!
2025-03-13 • lancaster NY
Drywall Ceiling Repair and Painting in Pine Tree Farms, Lancaster NY!
See More >
Popcorn Ceiling Removal and Refinishing Ceilings in Lancaster
2024-10-12 • lancaster NY
Popcorn Ceiling Removal and Refinishing Ceilings in Lancaster
See More >
Deck Painting in Lancaster NY – Rust Oleum 6x Review
2024-07-06 • lancaster NY
Deck Painting in Lancaster NY – Rust Oleum 6x Review
See More >
House Washing & Patio Sealing in Lancaster NY.
2024-06-24 • lancaster NY
House Washing & Patio Sealing in Lancaster NY.
See More >
Basement Ceiling Painting in Lancaster NY
2024-02-26 • lancaster NY
Basement Ceiling Painting in Lancaster NY
See More >
Auto-updated from blog feed. Last refresh: Sep 28, 2025 11:16pm

Need Interior Painting or Drywall Repair in lancaster NY? Request your interior painting estimate now
Dining room ceiling repair and ceiling painting in Pine Tree Farms, Lancaster NY 14086..

Interior Painters

We’ve been restoring and repainting homes across Lancaster NY since 2010. From vintage plaster in the Village, to drywall in newer developments, our work focuses on high quality interior painting, drywall repair, and plaster restoration. We've built our reputation one home at a time, carefully, cleanly, and without shortcuts.

We typically take on one project at a time, not because we’re slow, but because your home deserves full attention. Many painters chase volume. We don’t. We’re not out to paint 30 houses a summer — we’re here to repair, paint, and deliver the kind of finish work that doesn’t fit the "quick in and out" model.

We use the brush and roll method because it’s quieter, neater, and offers more control. We only spray when it’s appropriate, like new builds or unfinished basements, and even then, it's typically limited to primer or ceilings. Every finished wall, ceiling, and trim detail gets two full coats of paint and the care of hand painting.

Call/Text Carrigan Painting Today!

716-697-3560

Ceiling repair and painting in Pine Tree Farms, Lancaster NY 14086.

Expert Ceiling Repairs

Homes in Lancaster NY vary widely construction depending on the neighborhood’s age. Within the Village, it's common to find plaster over wood or rock lath, while newer sub-divisions typically feature standard drywall.

Many residential painters in Western New York mistakenly use drywall to repair plaster surfaces, but the materials aren’t interchangeable. Traditional plaster is finished by hand and worked until smooth and hard, whereas drywall panels are made in a factory and are perfectly flat. Drywall compound is especially easy to work with because it contains adhesives which allows it to stick to a variety of sufaces, after which it is to be sanded smooth. These differences can cause patchwork to stand out under critical light if not handled properly. At Carrigan Painting, we focus on ceiling repairs that blend seamlessly with the existing surface—plaster or drywall, so the repair never looks like a patch.


Kitchen ceiling repair and painting, Como Park, Lancaster NY 14086.


Ceiling Painters in Lancaster NY

Ceilings often suffer more wear than you'd expect — especially in kitchens where heat, moisture, and cooking residue gradually affect the surface. Our process includes repairing small imperfections, pole sanding for smoothness, and applying two coats of high-quality ceiling paint for a consistent, uniform finish. For textured ceilings like sand swirl, we’ll guide you on the ideal finish, such as matte or eggshell, to bring out the detail without drawing attention to blemishes.

716-697-3560
Do you need an experienced ceiling painter?

before and after interior painting of living room in Lancaster NY 14086.

Professioanl Painting Services


In WNY

Our list is short, ensuring quality and efficiency:
Interior Painting - We detail our precision.
Drywall Repair - We specialize in drywall repair!
Traditional Plaster Repair - We enjoy repairing plaster.
Ceiling Repair Services - Ceiling Restorations.
Wallpaper Removal - Please don't paint over it!
Popcorn Ceiling Removal - How do you like your popcorn?

Why Lancaster Homeowners Choose Carrigan Painting


  • Locally owned and operated by a 3rd-generation plasterer
  • Perfect 5-star rating for 15+ years
  • Specializing in interior painting and ceiling restoration for residential properties
  • Responsive, respectful, and clean.
  • The largest meticulously curated portfolio in Western New York

Frequently Asked Questions About Painting in Lancaster NY

Do you repair plaster ceilings in older Lancaster homes?

Yes. Many homes in the Village of Lancaster still have original plaster ceilings, often over wood or rock lath. We specialize in repairing cracks, holes, stains, and sagging areas so the finish looks original.

What's the best approach for painting ceilings with stains or water damage?

Ceilings that have suffered smoke, steam, or water damage need more than just paint. We use stain-blocking oil primers and apply two coats of quality ceiling paint for a clean, uniform finish.

Is brush and roll better than spraying for interior painting?

For occupied homes, absolutely. Brush and roll is cleaner, quieter, and gives us more control, especially on ceilings and trim. We may spray in new builds or unfinished basements.

Do you service all of Lancaster, including Bowmansville and areas near Como Park?

We do. Whether you're in Bowmansville, near Como Park, or on the north side closer to Transit Road, we handle interior painting and ceiling repairs throughout the entire Lancaster area.


Accountability

We document every job with in-progress and finished photos, not just for marketing, but to hold ourselves accountable. We’re proud to show our work.

Responsibility

We carry $1,000,000 in liability coverage and every team member is fully protected under New York State Workers’ Compensation.

Integrity

The price on your contract is the price you pay. We don’t play games with surprise charges. What we quote is what we honor.


716-697-3560

Freshly painted family room - lancaster NY

Freshly painted family room lancaster NY 14086.

Before and After, basement ceiling painting
Lancaster NY

Freshly painted 2 story foyer in Forest Heights Estates, lancaster, NY 14086.

Interior Painting in lancaster, NY

Freshly painted master bathroom in Lancaster NY 14086.

Scheduling With Us is Easy

  • Step 1

    Free Expert Consultation

    We’ll meet with you to walk through your project and answer questions. No two homes are the same, and we always take the time to understand what you're looking for.

    Estimates are typically scheduled weekday evenings after 5 PM, or Saturday mornings.

  • Step 2

    Securing Your Spot

    To reserve a place on our schedule, we usually require a one-third deposit. This deposit isn't cashed until we're ready to begin your project. We prefer checks, but also accept cash.

  • Step 3

    We Get It Done

    We typically work one job at a time so we can focus and finish what we start. But with complex ceiling repairs, especially plaster work, there's often unavoidable downtime built into the process. Plaster repairs are usually completed the same day, but then they need several days (sometimes a full week) to fully dry before we can paint them.

    Rather than wasting time during that curing period, we may rotate between two active jobs. It’s not about manpower, it’s about staying productive without compromising quality.

    And it's not about rushing, either. You simply can’t rush plaster work. We’ve tried to speed it up in the past, and it always ended up taking twice as long, because the material just doesn’t cooperate. The only thing that works is doing it right, and experience taught us that.

Reviews

From Satisfied clients

Christine P.⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

lancaster, NY

Amazing popcorn ceiling repair work....looks like new. Very well done!😊👍

Brian A.⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Lancaster NY

Carrigan Painting exceeded our expectations, we had multiple rooms done and what a difference!! If you need painting and drywall work done, I would highly recommend Carrigan Painting,.

Gary B.⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

West Seneca NY

I live in West Seneca and needed to have my living room ceiling repaired. A large section of popcorn ceiling was damaged and the painted surface came off the ceiling. I heard about Carrigan Painting and their expertise in this type of work. They came over, quoted the job, and fully explained the process to repair. Their work was precise and their ability to match the popcorn pattern was perfect. Their job setup, cleanliness, and final product met all expectations and cost. They did a great job!

Gary P.⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐

Williamsville, NY

Amazing work on plaster repairs and painting in our entry hall. We have an older home with a large curved ceiling, and Carrigan were the only people we trusted to actually repair the plaster. The other companies we received quotes from wanted to cover with squared off drywall. They did gorgeous work - just as good as brand new. Pleasant to work with and finished on time and below budget.

Please note that we do not service the city of Buffalo.

Looking for trusted painters in Lancaster NY?



716-697-3560